Forum topic: Cancelling Sponsors vs Suppliers cancelling contracts

United Kingdom Dan Silver Pitwall Supporter

145 races

6 championships

26 wins

64 podiums

Current team

United Kingdom Silver Cosmos
Division 1

If I'm reading the new rules right, then if I unilaterally cancel a sponsor's contract I have to pay up to 100% of the remaining fee to the sponsor. That doesn't seem wholly unreasonable, but if a supplier decides to do the same to me they can do so without paying me any compensation (financial or otherwise) whatsoever? This doesn't seem consistent...

Saturday 02:55 pm
+0

Spain Gareth Bennett

191 races

2 championships

28 wins

64 podiums

Current team

Spain Trackhouse Racing
Division 2.2

This is to simulate real life where companies can screw you over as much as they like but you always have to pay. :p

 

Jokes aside the current 100% cancellation fee is temporary on existing contract and will be a negotiated percentage for new ones. 

 

I think the intent of the suppliers dropping out is as much a game design philosophy as "reality".

 

(Like if this game truly simulated reality we'd have no refuelling, no overtaking and penalties assigned at pretty much random (and of course a penalty for Gasly )). Some of it is just for gameplay/design/balance reasons.

Saturday 07:00 pm
+1

Belgium Frank Van Laere Pitwall Administrator

Lokeren

316 races

1 championships

9 wins

34 podiums

Current team

Belgium Skylark Racing
Division 3.1

#1 by Dan Silver
If I'm reading the new rules right, then if I unilaterally cancel a sponsor's contract I have to pay up to 100% of the remaining fee to the sponsor. That doesn't seem wholly unreasonable, but if a supplier decides to do the same to me they can do so without paying me any compensation (financial or otherwise) whatsoever? This doesn't seem consistent...

What Gareth said. I couldn't just randomly assign percentage, so it's fixed to 100% for each existing contract.

Yesterday 11:07 am
+0

United Kingdom Dan Silver Pitwall Supporter

145 races

6 championships

26 wins

64 podiums

Current team

United Kingdom Silver Cosmos
Division 1

My point wasn't about the 100%/negotiated sponsors fee - it's more on Gareths first response. I.e. I have to pay to exit my contract with a sponsor, but my suppliers don't have to pay to exit one with me? Doesn't seem balanced... 

Yesterday 02:38 pm
+0

Belgium Frank Van Laere Pitwall Administrator

Lokeren

316 races

1 championships

9 wins

34 podiums

Current team

Belgium Skylark Racing
Division 3.1

It's a different situation imo. With suppliers you are paying for something and you're not getting it. So you don't need to pay any more. It's something we can look into in the future, but I don't feel that a supplier paying cash because they can't supply in 2 seasons is right.

Yesterday 03:52 pm
+0

Malta J Spiteri Pitwall Supporter

587 races

3 championships

12 wins

45 podiums

Current team

Brazil CJ Motorsport
Division 2.4

An idea could be that, when a supplier pulls out, already signed teams are given the possibility to keep a normal contract for the next season at an X% discount (equal for all teams or depending on the deal signed) on the agreed fee but also offering free withdrawal to the team. 

 

That way teams would not lose all invested points ending with nothing but on the other hand still allowing ambitious teams to find a better team.  

22 hours ago
+0

Austria Philip E. Pitwall Administrator

https://superfly.fm

639 races

20 championships

93 wins

258 podiums

Current team

Austria Pirate Panda Race
Division 2.4

I think two different things are getting mixed up here, so let me split them.

Sponsors
A sponsor can’t just walk away. It can only end the contract in response to something the team did, i.e. missing the agreed number of races. The manager, on the other hand, can cancel deliberately, for example after a costly typo (300k instead of 3 million per week). That’s a choice, so it comes with a fee on the remaining contract value: 100% for existing contracts, negotiated for new ones. Fair enough.

Suppliers
Different story. Neither side can leave mid-season. A team can end future seasons for 500 admin points. A supplier, however, can leave ahead of the committed time, without cause and without any consequence. That’s exactly what a sponsor can’t do, and right now it’s a loose end. In my view suppliers shouldn’t be able to do so.

22 hours ago
+0

Malta J Spiteri Pitwall Supporter

587 races

3 championships

12 wins

45 podiums

Current team

Brazil CJ Motorsport
Division 2.4

Apologies if I hijacked the topic - was referring to when a supplier withdraws before the committed season but suggesting something to offer something for the points spent by the team. 

 

Just to clarify, supplier is committed up to season 5 but withdraws from season 2. Suggestion would be to offer signed teams a way to keep the supplier but for a normal deal for season 3 (even when they had partner or works). If the team wants another supplier for season 3, the game would offer free cancellation of the supplier.

 

Hijack concluded. 

22 hours ago
+0

Austria Philip E. Pitwall Administrator

https://superfly.fm

639 races

20 championships

93 wins

258 podiums

Current team

Austria Pirate Panda Race
Division 2.4

Suppliers: When a supplier breaks a future contract, the team already loses nothing further, except everything it invested in negotiating it. That’s the problem, and why I don’t think suppliers should be able to do this at all.
A team pays 500 admin points to end future seasons; a supplier pays nothing, even though the team gave it no reason to leave.

22 hours ago
+1

Netherlands Jan Janssen Pitwall Supporter

215 races

11 championships

42 wins

102 podiums

Current team

Netherlands Chorus
Division 3.2

I think this is the difference:

 

When a supplier has 'committed until season 10' (for example) and you decide to negotiate a contract until season 12.. that's a risk you take as manager. If the supplier quits after season 10 - that's fair game and a possibility known to all beforehand.

 

When a supplier has 'committed until season 10' (for example), but pulls back unexpectedly after season 8.. that's breaking a contract to the teams it signed. There should be some compensation, whether it's points, money, or something else. It could also be one of those event decisions, where a manager can choose between four options on how they want to handle it. But a supplier pulling back within this scenario isn't fair or realistic without some sort of compensation. (Although I like that there can be some uncertainty until late in a season whether or not a supplier will be active in the next. High risk, high reward.)

 

When a sponsor cancels on a team, that's the managers own fault for missing x races, so no compensation needed there.

21 hours ago
+0

Reply

Error

Guests can't post in the forum. Please sign in to be able to post in the forums.