Forum topic: Skills

Belgium Frank Van Laere Pitwall Administrator

Lokeren

316 races

1 championships

9 wins

34 podiums

Current team

Belgium Skylark Racing
Division 3.1

Hi everyone,

Now that we're close to ending the beta I was considering some things before the start of the game.
Please keep the topic constructive, and think about the long term and not just for your own short term benefit. Also, every person will be a free person when the game starts, so there shouldn't be a benefit for everyone.

Questions to answer:
1. How do you feel about the fact that the person skills are hidden? Does it make Pitwall special/different for you, or is it a frustration?

2. Do you feel that you have enough information that should help you to determine whether a person is better than another? Is there any profession (driver/designer/mechanic/commercial/scout/coach) that you feel is lacking in information to determine his skill.

3. Do you think Pitwall v2 would be a better game with the skills shown on a scale of 1 to 5 (like we had in PW1)?

4. If you had the ultimate decision: would you show the skills or hide them?

Thank you all for the information. Ultimately I want to keep the game fun and I tried to add something special by hiding the skills. But I'm interested in knowing if people actually like it or whether people feel it's a frustration more than a nifty feature.
So please keep in mind that if all is shown, it will be less of a guessing game with the top teams going after the highest stats persons. But that of course it wouldn't be a stats from 1-10. It would be from 1-5 so that there's still some mystery included.
December 4, 2014 01:44 pm
+0

Deleted member

698 races

22 championships

107 wins

238 podiums

Current team

I like hidden skills but I d like to have much better scout reports and an idea how reliable those scouts are.
The reports should give indication of certain areas of the drivers skills. The better the scout the more in one report. To get a full report the drivers should be scouted 3-7 times depending on the scouts skills.
The accuracy of those reports should be in a range of lets say +-10% so a very good skill can be reported one skill below to one skill above, also depending on the scouts skills.

no knowing anything about drivers and staff related to skill is challenging but also frustrating - some hints regarding the skills would be appreciated.
December 4, 2014 03:38 pm
+0

Liechtenstein Matthew Dellit

159 races

2 championships

8 wins

42 podiums

Current team

Liechtenstein DrakenSport Racing

1) I find the hidden stats to be frustrating, as there isn't any way to ever tell what they are. Using an example from the Football Manager series of games, in that you only know the stats for your own staff/players. All other players you have a common knowledge base (player X is really fast, player Y is terrible at headers, that kind of thing). The common knowledge base gives you rough estimates of some of a players skills. You then have to scout them to gain the other stats.

I don't mind if the actual stats for the drivers/staff start off hidden, but we should be able to find out those stats. We should also have an idea of people who are talented/lacking in certain areas. Everyone knows that Adrian Newey is a genius with his aerodynamics, but the other people in his staff are also obviously skilled, so we know they are talented, just not the specifics.

2) No, I don't think we have enough information now. The only skill we can see is experience in a staff role. Take Børge Skjervstad as an example, he's one of the best drivers we've found so far, but his experience when i first signed him was only Okay, and not superb. I decided to sign him because I liked his name, there was no other reason as I had no idea at all if he was good or not.

I think all professions are lacking because experience doesn't equate to good or bad, it just means they've done more.

3) Yes I think Pitwall would be better if we could see (even with some error) the ratings of people's skills on the 1-5 scale, even with some error until scouted fully or even if there is still some error involved until you've actually signed them.

4) I would show some skills (so we could search for drivers good in the wet), but require scouting to get full data on them.

Which also means scouting needs to be better. I think we should be able to assign quick scout reports that a scout will return in a set amount of time, maybe a day. This report will only be basic information. And more detailed reports will take days/weeks/multiple times scouted to receive the information.

Scouting should be much less random, and much more frequent. We should also be able to scout any driver/staff member, whether they race or not. As it stands, we only get driver scout reports, and those are only if the driver is active in a race. I've still got a driver in my scout queue because he hasn't been a guest driver since i added him to the queue.
December 4, 2014 06:14 pm
+0

Deleted member

471 races

0 championships

5 wins

46 podiums

Current team

1 Its Ok
2 almost no information
3 yes and no
4 for own personal after some period (1 season) YES
Designers/Mechanics on my league slightly better knowledge after every new part released on track
Comercials only if we are negociating on same sponsors or same supliers
Scouts only if we hve same person on scouting simultaneouslly
Trainers after every race we are participating (both)
Drivers after every interaction on track
December 4, 2014 06:58 pm
+0

Deleted member

506 races

11 championships

73 wins

170 podiums

Current team

i totally agree with Matthew
December 4, 2014 08:03 pm
+0

United Kingdom Adam Eggbeer

1156 races

45 championships

235 wins

565 podiums

Current team

United Kingdom Team Destroyers

1. I like the fact that the skills are hidden. It means that you don't know if you have the best driver/staff member or someone else does. I can see that it can be a frustration but I feel it would be a bigger frustration if you could see who were the best and you couldn't sign them. At least with no/limited information you can sign a great driver/staff member that everyone else has missed.

2. I think there could be more information for each of the roles but as has been said by Matt, make it so these people need to be scouted. It would take time and several scouting trips (6-10 lasting several days each) to get a good estimate of a persons skills and to reveal stats but they should be 90% accurate at most so we don't get managers knowing exactly who are the best people in each role.

3. Only if it happens through scouting.

4. I would only show them after enough scouting has been performed.

Quite frankly, I haven't seen the real need for a scout in Pitwall and I feel this role can become more important if they could find out the ratings of people with good accuracy.
December 5, 2014 02:24 pm
+0

Australia Tim Watts

Parkes

156 races

4 championships

14 wins

32 podiums

Current team

I think having some idea of what your getting is important.
It doesnt need to be exact but some indication would be handy.
What about creating a human resources position where it is there job to recommend people to hire. You give them parameters on the type of staff you want and when they pop up you get a notification. The better the HR manager the more accurate their recommendations are.
They could also be responsible for staff training etc.
December 6, 2014 01:15 am
+0

Japan Robert Bouchard

Shinshiro, Aichi, Japan

419 races

5 championships

16 wins

94 podiums

Current team

1. I love the fact that skills are hidden as I expected certain aspects from some of my drivers but they turned out to be completely different. It brought a realistic feel to drivers as it's really is a leap of faith when signing a driver if he is going to be better or not.

That being said I think it would also be nice to know some of the stats but again only if they were to be scouted for!!

2. No, I don't feel there is enough information or knowledge from our end to understand the key aspect to look for a good Driver or a great driver. Add this to staff makes it more confusing and frustrating. It should be more clear and become even more clear if you scout personal.

3. No, I don't think Pitwall would be a better game if we could see the stats. I think this should be something that we find out over time through testing drivers, developing drivers and scouting....

4. My choice would be to leave them as they stand but increase the scouting role to show some clear picture of the staff that we have signed for our current team. Also clarify the difference cue for a great driver verus a good driver.

Overall, I will agree with Adam that scouts really don't play a large role in the current game and this could be increase to help show some of the stats!!
December 7, 2014 04:29 am
+0

Belgium Frank Van Laere Pitwall Administrator

Lokeren

316 races

1 championships

9 wins

34 podiums

Current team

Belgium Skylark Racing
Division 3.1

Thanks for the feedback guys! I had a similar idea of showing the skills based on scout reports. I've made some changes to my idea based on your feedback, and I've integrated this now in the game. Check out the changelog for more information.
December 7, 2014 09:27 pm
+0

Malta J Spiteri Pitwall Supporter

587 races

3 championships

12 wins

45 podiums

Current team

Brazil CJ Motorsport
Division 2.4

I've read all the forum posts and to be honest I'm feeling in the minority :p. I'd like to open this by saying that, when I read the blog post, I was dubious about whether this was possible to do and thought quite frankly that it was a horrible idea (sorry Frank). Now that I saw the feature for 5 seasons, I have a better idea of it.

1. Apart from Pitwall, I'm currently playing IGP Manager, that is the opposite of the skills idea we have because all skills are shown from 1-10. Personally, I see that the hidden skills feature is better than IGP's system and I see this as making Pitwall. I like the idea behind this a d I think that the problem is not the idea but the implementation.

2. I do not think that we have enough information for all types of staff and drivers. Again, the idea was correct but what was not considered (I think) is the enormous ratio between persons and members and teams. The plan was to make us look at the results to check who is best. But a lot of drivers are still that nobody has signed and therefore we have no information about them. There could be some star persons who are still left unsigned. This is worse for other staff (apart from drivers) since they don't show any results gained by them personally but depend on the drivers.

3. This is the key question. Even though I was skeptic about the hidden skills, I now find the idea of the game without this feature hard to imagine. But I think that an approximate skill indication can be good for the game. As others have said, it could be based on the scout's skill, if we can know whether the scout is good himself. Another idea could be to add some sort of rating which shows the overall skills (similar to how many of us use experience).

4. If it was my decision I would leave the original skills hidden but show an approximate rating from 1-5. I would also increase the information given in scout reports and make it more reliable and correct.

As an additional point, I think that a look has to be taken to the youth drivers. Currently, it is almost impossible to see whether the driver is improving throughout the training. Youth drivers have to have more information and should show a full skill set with some margin of error depending on the skill of either the scout or the coach. It could be in the person page or as a report on request. However, potential should be shown to everyone.

I would like to see a skill system based on real-life. No one knows what are the skills of each driver but everyone knows that Newey is good in are o or Kobayashi is good in passing. But there's the little personal bias and margin of error. I hope that the end result is the best that can be in Pitwall.
December 7, 2014 09:35 pm
+0

Reply

Error

Guests can't post in the forum. Please sign in to be able to post in the forums.