I've read all the forum posts and to be honest I'm feeling in the minority

. I'd like to open this by saying that, when I read the blog post, I was dubious about whether this was possible to do and thought quite frankly that it was a horrible idea (sorry Frank). Now that I saw the feature for 5 seasons, I have a better idea of it.
1. Apart from Pitwall, I'm currently playing IGP Manager, that is the opposite of the skills idea we have because all skills are shown from 1-10. Personally, I see that the hidden skills feature is better than IGP's system and I see this as making Pitwall. I like the idea behind this a d I think that the problem is not the idea but the implementation.
2. I do not think that we have enough information for all types of staff and drivers. Again, the idea was correct but what was not considered (I think) is the enormous ratio between persons and members and teams. The plan was to make us look at the results to check who is best. But a lot of drivers are still that nobody has signed and therefore we have no information about them. There could be some star persons who are still left unsigned. This is worse for other staff (apart from drivers) since they don't show any results gained by them personally but depend on the drivers.
3. This is the key question. Even though I was skeptic about the hidden skills, I now find the idea of the game without this feature hard to imagine. But I think that an approximate skill indication can be good for the game. As others have said, it could be based on the scout's skill, if we can know whether the scout is good himself. Another idea could be to add some sort of rating which shows the overall skills (similar to how many of us use experience).
4. If it was my decision I would leave the original skills hidden but show an approximate rating from 1-5. I would also increase the information given in scout reports and make it more reliable and correct.
As an additional point, I think that a look has to be taken to the youth drivers. Currently, it is almost impossible to see whether the driver is improving throughout the training. Youth drivers have to have more information and should show a full skill set with some margin of error depending on the skill of either the scout or the coach. It could be in the person page or as a report on request. However, potential should be shown to everyone.
I would like to see a skill system based on real-life. No one knows what are the skills of each driver but everyone knows that Newey is good in are o or Kobayashi is good in passing. But there's the little personal bias and margin of error. I hope that the end result is the best that can be in Pitwall.